NFL coaches can have a greater impact on the outcome of a game than any other coaches in any other sport. They can actually dictate what their players do almost every moment of the game. They must make real-time decisions about watches, timeouts, complex games, and so on. They can destroy or steal the game.
Welcome to the CBS Sports official coaching rating. Over the past couple of weeks, we rated the top 10 players in each group of positions – from quarterbacks in kickers and players (Yes indeed). Now we turn our attention to the trainers. Below you will find my rating of the top 10 trainers in Nfl now.
But first, a few notes about the list:
- It does not depend on who, I think, will win the majority of games in 2020. If that were the case, Andy Reid and John Harbo would be taller than Bill Belichick, because they now have better football teams than Belichick.
- This is not entirely based on past success. If that were the case, Pete Carroll and Mike Tomlin would be taller.
- For Eagles especially fans: Sean McVeigh has won roughly 69 percent of his games. Doug Pederson won about 59 percent of his games. McVeigh took a bunch of evil for the bad season of 2019 … when Jacks still won nine games. Pederson won nine games in a row in a row. He also went 7–9 in his first season, which McVeigh never did. On this note, Super Bowles is not the only thing that matters. I am not going to base my ratings on one game. You can. There is definitely an argument for Pederson because of McVey. But if you don’t think there is an argument for McVey because of Pederson, you are probably a fan of the Eagles or are weighing too much the outcome of one game.
- The next three trainers would be: Bruce Arians, Sean McDermott and Mike Wrabel.
To the list itself.
ten. VikingsMike Zimmer
Mike Zimmer seems to be underestimated. Here's what he did as a Viking coach over the past six seasons:
He won 59.9 percent of his games, which is enough to record 57-38-1. He was in the playoffs in half of his six seasons, although he was stuck in the same division as Aaron RogersHe would be 3-2 instead of 2-3 in the playoffs if Blair Walsh Blair Walsh did not cost him. As a defense-minded coach, he always gets the most out of Viking defense. Over the course of six seasons, the Viking defense was in the top 10 points that were allowed five times. The only time they did not finish in the top 10 is his first season, when they took 11th place.
Zimmer is not an ideal coach. He probably should win more playoff games to gain more respect. But he is a defense coach who always gets results from his defense.
9. Oryol Doug Pederson
For four seasons with the Eagles, despite the fact that he was dealing with a number of injuries, Doug Pederson holds a record of 38–26, which is quite enough for a win percentage of 59.4. He reached the playoffs in three of four seasons. But of course, the real reason Pederson is rated so high is the 2017 season, when he sent the Orlov to the top of the NFC playoffs picture and then injured at the end of the season to Carson Wentz getting the absolute maximum from the backup defender Nick Fallswhich has turned into Super bowl MVP Although the Eagles have not used their potential in the past two seasons, they still managed to get through the playoffs in both seasons. Pederson showed willingness to be aggressive – especially in the Super Bowl against patriots – This should appeal to NFL fans who want the game to continue to evolve.
8. SiouxPete carroll
If this list was based solely on wins and losses, Pete Carroll would be closer to the top. In his 10 seasons as a Seahawks trainer, he posted a record of 100-59-1 (62.8 percent). He led them to two Super Bowls, one of which they won. He missed the playoffs only twice. Since he got Russell WilsonHe missed the postseason. With Wilson, Carroll's Seahawks never ended worse than 9-7. Carroll has always been a castle to make this list. If coaches are judged by victories and defeats (spoiler: they are), then Carroll is one of the best coaches in football.
So, why did Carroll take such a low place after the coaches who achieved far less results than he did? There is no simple answer to this question, but it is important to remember that this list is looking forward. This is not only based on past success. And over the past few seasons, Carroll and the rest of his coaching staff have shown reluctance to develop in a changing game. It is his stubbornness in establishing a run that sticks out, which often requires Wilson to help out the attack from the difficult situations of the third down. Because analytics has become a weapon that smart teams are like Crows – With the ability to exploit their opponents, the Seahawks are behind.
Carroll is still a great coach. He perfectly develops defense. He deserves credit for Wilson's development from picking the third round to one of the top three defenders in football. But as the league continues to evolve, Carroll must evolve with it. At the moment, he certainly did not. If he does, he will jump right into the top five.
7. SteelersMike Tomlin
Mike Tomlin had a successful coaching career, which includes two trips to the Super Bowl and one championship, but the 2019 season, which ended without appearing in the playoffs, could be his best coaching job. Despite the loss Ben Retlisberger at the beginning to go and be forced to wait a year with Mason Rudolph and Devlin Hodges in quarterback, who combined to throw 18 touchdowns and 17 interceptions, the Steelers managed to win eight games, running their incredible defense, which ranked third in DVOA and the first takeaway. They lacked only a competent defender.
As already mentioned, Tomlin won one Super Bowl in two trips. He also won 133 games in 13 seasons with a win rate of 64.2. He never ended up with a record below .500. He is surprisingly consistent. However, it seems that he does not always get the credit he deserves.
6. Rams Sean McVeigh
Despite the fact that Sean McVay was criticized after the disappointing season of 2019, it is important to present this disappointing season in context. McVay hired at the age of 30, 24-8 in his first two seasons with two playoffs and a trip to the Super Bowl. His disappointing 2019 season still included nine wins, which means his record after three seasons is 33-15, which means his win rate is 68.8. Obviously, given his relative inexperience, there is a problem with the sample size that will be resolved at the right time, but it is worth noting that he has a higher percentage of wins than every trainer on this list. That is why he praised it highly.
So why did he rate it low? It all comes down to the 2019 season, when the defenders finally figured out how to stop McVeigh's once-vaunted crime. In 2017 Rams' crime took sixth place in DVOA – a year before the arrival of McVeigh, they took last place. In 2018 they finished secondBut in 2019 Rams crime fell to the 17th. Perhaps this was just a one-year case, but McVey should make adjustments in 2020 if they are going to survive the most difficult division in football – NFC West has three coaches on this list.
However, this was an unreal start to his coaching career. Despite the disappointing nature of the 2019 season, let's not lose sight of how well McVeigh achieved his age and how terrible Rams was when he inherited the team.
five. 49ersKyle Shanahan
No wonder if Shanahan, who is only 40 years old, becomes the best coach in the league. He, of course, on this trajectory. Like Andy Reid, he is a striker.
It is hard to really rely on statistics or his career resume, because before the start of the 2019 season, he got a bad hand. 49ers kicked off in 2017 Brian Hoyer and C.J. Beethard in quarterback, combining 1-10 with these two quarterbacks until Jimmy Garoppolo arrived through trading and won the last five games of the season. Then, in 2018, Garoppolo tore off his ACL in week 3, forcing the 49ers to end the season with Beathard and Nick MullensAs a result, Shanahan posted 10-22 entries in his first two seasons as an NFL head coach.
Finally, in 2019, we saw what Shanahan could do with a competent defender. With a healthy Garoppolo, 49ers broke a 13-3 record, waltzed their way through the NFC portion of the playoff grid, and then lost a few minutes to win the Super Bowl. While some will undoubtedly rush to notice that this is the second leader of the Super Bowl who was cut off by Shanahan (he was the coordinator of the 28-3 attack). Falcons) we probably shouldn't blame Shanahan, given he prepared the winning game, which Garoppolo missed. If Garoppolo falls into this throw, Shanahan will win his first Super Bowl. Instead, Garoppolo missed, and now Shanahan is addressing his ability to win big games.
This seems unfair. But even if you agree with the belief that Shanahan is suffocating in big moments, you can still recognize his greatness as an attacking player, realizing that he is a young coach. He was the head coach for only three seasons. He had only one quarterback for one of these three seasons. Shanahan must continue to climb this list.
4. The SaintsSean Payton
After a three-year period of mediocrity, as a result of which they won seven games in a season from 2014 to 16, Sean Payton Saints regained their elite status. NFL Team with 37 wins in the last three seasons. If it weren't for some terrible luck in the postseason, they could have picked up another Super Bowl. However, even without a second championship, Payton Saints remains one of the best league teams from year to year, making Payton one of the best league coaches.
In his 13 seasons, he holds a record of 131-77, which is enough for 63.0 percent of victories. He made the playoffs eight times. He won the Super Bowl. His insults are almost always good. In 11 out of 13 seasons, the Saints finished with a top 10 assault on points.
Payton is another Super Bowl not spoken of as one of the league's best coaches. Given that the Saints are almost always in the playoffs, where their luck has completely evaporated in recent seasons, they will have a decent chance to do so. But with Drew Brice approaching retirement, Payton does not have enough time to get his second. Even if he doesn't win another Super Bowl, Payton’s legacy as a great coach is already safe.
3. Ravens John Harbo
First, let's look at John Harbo's resume, because it is commendable. Over his 12 seasons as a Voronov’s coach, he wins an average of 9.8 per season, enters the playoffs eight times, won the Super Bowl and has just received his first coach’s prize of the year. But what has strengthened Harbo’s status as head coach is his work over the past two seasons, especially with Lamar Jackson,
First, Harbo made the transition from Joe Flacco Lamar Jackson in the middle of last season. Despite their sharp difference in playing styles, Ravens went 6-1 with Jackson in quarterback. Last season, the Ravens continued to make changes to their crime in order to satisfy Jackson's strengths. This may seem obvious, but in the NFL this does not always happen. Coaches sometimes resist change. They would prefer their players to fit their system, rather than setting up a system around their players. Harbo, along with the rest of his coaching staff, made a perfect attack on Jackson's undeniable talent and was rewarded with a terrific season 14-2, which ended too early in the playoffs. But with Jackson set as the team's long-term starter, the Ravens are about to build this season and ultimately take it one step further.
Harbo also showed willingness use analytics make the best decisions in the game. While many NFL coaches are opposed to change, Harbo accepted the change. Ravens converted 17 fourth falls with a high NFL level with a success rate of 70.8 percent.
It is Harbo’s willingness to develop that makes me feel confident that his place on this list will age well. Not to mention the fact that he is going to be paired with Jackson over the next decade. The pair have already won 19 of 22 regular season games together. All that is missing is success in January.
2. leadersAndy reid
Finally, Andy Reid received the award for his stellar career that he deserved. Having gone 130-93-1 with the Eagles for 14 years, but failing to capture the Lombardi Trophy, and after receiving an average of almost 11 wins per season for the first six years he led the leaders, Reed finally put it all together in his 21- m season as NFL head coach. In 2019, Raid Chiefs went 12-4 to bring his record with the team to 77-35 (68.8 percent) before winning the Super Bowl. Raid summary completed. He won 61.8 percent of his games in two of his coaching positions. He is the seventh in all time in victories. He has a Super Bowl. And with Patrick Magomes Locked as the team’s long-term starting quarterback, Reed is set to jump to record victories over the years and probably add more Lombardi trophies to his office.
This is more than just victory and success in the playoffs. It is also about how Raid teams win.
He is the best striker in the league. Of course, there is an argument that any team will be successful with the Mahomes in the quarterback, but it is hard to imagine the other team having the same success with the Mahomes that the leaders enjoy for two full seasons. Together, Mahomes and Reid boast almost the same, but slightly better percentage of winnings (including the playoffs) than Bill Belichick and Tom Brady win percentage together. Without the Raid, it is impossible to imagine that Magomez will become the second quarterback in the history of the NFL, who will throw 5,000-odd yards and 50-odd touchdowns in one season in his first ever season as an NFL starting quarterback. And let's not forget that Reid was very successful with a quarterback in the style of a game manager in Alex smithHe managed to win games with someone like Matt moore just recently, last season. There is a reason that Raid teams are almost always flawless in attack. These are not always advocates. But it is always a coach. In the 21st season of Raid as a coach, his violations ended in the top 10 on points 13 times.
if Belichik resigns before the Raid, he will be replaced by Raid on this list.
1. Patriots Bill Belichik
The undisputed best coach in the NFL, Bill Belichick, is also arguably the greatest coach in sports history. Heading into his 21st season in charge of the Patriots, Belichik won an amazing 74.1 percent of his games in the regular season with the team. He wins an average of 11.9 per season. He was in the playoffs in 17 of the 20 seasons, posting a record of 30-11 in the postseason, which is enough for 73.2 percent of wins. He was in nine Super Bowls – again in 20 seasons. He won six Super Bowls – the most in NFL history. Damn, even before he arrived in New England, he managed to take Cleveland Browns in the playoffs. He even won the playoff game in Cleveland. The Browns have not won the playoff game since then.
No one should question Belichik's position at the top of this list. His greatness is beyond doubt.
However, he faces perhaps the biggest challenge in his coaching career. With Tom Brady traveling freely from New England to Tampa Bay, Belichick will be forced to win the game without perhaps the best defender of all time. But the evidence suggests that Belichik will be able to overcome Brady's departure. He had won a lot without Brady before. In 2008, patriots went 11-5 s Matt Kassel after Brady tore off his ACL in week 1. In 2016, when Brady was suspended from his first four games, the Patriots went 3-1 with their second and third defenders. If someone survives Brady's departure, this is Belichik, who is constantly at the forefront of innovation and always demonstrates a willingness to adapt and the desire to form a team around his strengths, whatever they may be.
No matter how the 2020 season unfolds for the patriots, Belichik will remain on this list until he resigns.